Salamandastron by Brian Jacques
Lisa, aged 10, from USA.
Rating: Brilliant.
Opinion of the plot.
The plot was extremely exciting, and I kept wanting to read on so I could find out
what happened.
Favourite character and why?
Tammo, because I like the hares in the stories and because he's 'perilous'.
Who will the book appeal to most and why?
This book would appeal to fantasy readers that love animals and don't mind a little
violence. The books in this series have a lot of war, and animals play human roles.
Would you recommend the book and why?
I would definetely recommend this book, because it is very interesting and
suspensful.
Could any improvements be made and how?
I don't think there needs to be any improvements. The book was really great.
Long Patrol by Brian Jacques
Samantha, aged 11, from Riyadh,
Saudi Arabia. Rating: Brilliant.
Opinion of the plot.
It's pretty easy to follow. Humans don't exist. Sometimes it's funny, at other
times it's bloodthirsty. It's part of a series of 13 books.
Favourite character and why?
Tammo, because I like the hares in the stories and because he's 'perilous'.
Who will the book appeal to most and why?
I think it will appeal to people who like reading;about animals,battles,people who
have a big imagination and for anyone who likes a good read.
Would you recommend the book and why?
I would recomend it to anybody who likes the things above. I think they would enjoy
it. ( I've read each one at least twice!! )
Could any improvements be made and how?
I think the book could have been made a little more interesting in the beginning
and at the end.
Redwall by Brian
Jacques
Luke, aged
11, from Chesham, England. Rating: Brilliant.
Opinion of the plot.
Good.
Favourite character and why?
Clunny the
scourge because he is the bad
guy.
Who will the book appeal to most and why?
11 up.
Would you recommend the book and why?
I would recommend
this book to people who like action books because it has a lot of
action.
Could any improvements be made and how?
No.
Misty, aged 12, from Diamond
Bar, USA. Rating: Brilliant.
Opinion of the plot.
I thought the plot was great because it involved defeating an evil rat,
finding a legendary sword and much, much more like defeating the evil snake Asmodeus.
Favourite character and why?
Matthias the mouse is my favorite character because he's got a lot of
spunk. Not to mention he is the star of the book. He is also very brave.
Who will the book appeal to most and why?
The book will appeal to people who love to read( it's 333 pages!), love
fantasies, and animals. (It's got a lot of everything).
Would you recommend the book and why?
I would recommend the book because it is very exciting.
Could any improvements be made and how?
Yes, there can be improving. How? Well a lot of animals die (tons of rats,
mice, shrews, & woodland creatures) Mabey not a lot of good ones should die.
Mattimeo by
Brian Jacques
Phil, aged 10. Rating:
Brilliant.
Opinion of the plot.
Very exciting.
Favourite character and why?
Matthias because he is good..
Who will the book appeal to most and why?
Other people because it just will.
Would you recommend the book and why?
Yes, because other people will like it.
Could any improvements be made and how?
NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Is there a book you would like to review? Write a review now.
Read some more reviews.
|
